What You’ll Need
– 1 pre-made angel food cake, sliced about an inch thick — don’t stress over the exact measurement, just slice it like bread
– For the syrup: 1/4 cup sugar, 1/4 cup fresh lemon juice, 1/4 cup water, 1/4 teaspoon almond extract (this is the ingredient people always ask about — it’s subtle, don’t skip it, don’t double it either, I did that once and it took over)
– For the cream layer: 2/3 cup sugar, 1 pound cream cheese at true room temperature, 2 cups heavy cream, also room temperature, which feels backwards for cream but trust the process
– For layering: 2 pints blueberries, 2 pints strawberries, hulled and sliced — I eyeball this part entirely, more berries never hurt anybody
Patriotic Berry Trifle
How I Actually Make It
Start the syrup first, because it needs to cool a little before you brush it on, and there’s no sense standing around waiting on it once everything else is ready to go. Sugar, lemon juice, water, into a saucepan, medium-high, stir until you can’t feel sugar grit on the back of the spoon anymore. Off the heat, stir in the almond extract. It’ll smell like a bakery for a second. Set it aside.
Brush the syrup on both sides of every cake slice — I use a pastry brush, my mother used a spoon and just sort of drizzled it, either works — and then cut the slices into cubes, about an inch, though some come out bigger and some smaller and that’s just how cake cubing goes, nobody’s grading you.
For the cream part: beat the sugar and cream cheese together until it’s smooth — really smooth, no lumps, this is where the room temperature thing matters most — and then pour in the heavy cream and keep beating until it thickens up and looks like whipped cream, which takes longer than you’d think, longer than regular whipped cream by itself, so don’t panic and don’t walk away from the mixer or you’ll end up with butter, which happened to my daughter-in-law Renee her first time making this and she texted me a very alarmed photo.
Now you build it. Half the cake cubes go in the bottom of your trifle dish. Blueberries scattered over that. Half the cream mixture dolloped on — and I do mean dolloped, don’t try to spread it perfectly smooth, it’ll settle on its own — over the blueberries. Then a layer of strawberries on top of that.
Repeat: the rest of the cake cubes, more blueberries, the rest of the cream. And then the top — this is the part people remember, where you arrange the last of the strawberries and blueberries in some kind of pattern, stars or stripes or whatever you’re going for, or just a pretty scatter if you’re not feeling that ambitious that particular year, which, fair. Cover it, get it in the fridge for at least an hour. I usually do mine the night before, honestly, because mornings of the Fourth are not for trifle-assembling, they’re for finding everyone’s shoes.
If You Want to Change Things Up
My daughter does this with a yellow box cake instead of angel food sometimes, which is heavier and not really the same dessert if you ask me, but she likes it that way and I’m not going to argue with her in her own kitchen. You could swap the almond extract for vanilla if almond’s not your thing, though I think you lose something. Some years I’ve layered in a few raspberries just for the color, and once — only once — I tried a layer of crushed pretzels for some salty crunch idea I’d seen somewhere, and it was a mistake, it got soggy and weird by hour two, so I’m not going to pretend that one worked.
Keeping It
It holds in the fridge two, maybe three days, covered, though the cake does start softening up the longer it sits — by day three it’s more pudding-like than trifle-like, still tastes fine, just a different texture situation. I would not try to freeze this. I did try freezing half a leftover one once and what came out the other side was sad and watery and not worth the freezer space.
Anyway. It’s a good one. Just maybe hold it on your lap in the car instead of the floor
ADVERTISEMENT
